Should I buy from the dealer or a regular auto shop?

Posted by admin on November 28, 2009

I need a new alternator for my Corolla. Should I get it from the dealer or is it ok to get from a regular auto shop (non-Toyota). The Toyota part has a 12 month warranty. What do you think?

Do yourself a favour and go somewhere other than the dealer. You can get the part from and aftermarket manufacturer for probably around half of what the dealer will charge you. You drive a corolla, not a lexus – don’t worry too much about where you get your parts from – just look for the best deal from a reputable manufacturer of parts.

Through my experience, aftermarket parts (from reputable manufacturers) far exceed the quality of OEM and always cost less and last longer.

Oh yeah, thought I might add this too – take a good look at the alternator – I would be willing to bet that it’s not even made by Toyota – probably Fujitsu or Mitsubishi…

  1. Claws-Of-Insanity Said,

    go with the warranty :)
    References :

  2. gib0002 Said,

    Always best to go to a dealer for repairs during the cars first 10 years. The repairmen know the car well. Has parts on hand.
    References :

  3. Big L Said,

    Do yourself a favour and go somewhere other than the dealer. You can get the part from and aftermarket manufacturer for probably around half of what the dealer will charge you. You drive a corolla, not a lexus – don’t worry too much about where you get your parts from – just look for the best deal from a reputable manufacturer of parts.

    Through my experience, aftermarket parts (from reputable manufacturers) far exceed the quality of OEM and always cost less and last longer.

    Oh yeah, thought I might add this too – take a good look at the alternator – I would be willing to bet that it’s not even made by Toyota – probably Fujitsu or Mitsubishi…
    References :

  4. Gordon Said,

    you should be able to find OEM parts at a parts shop… the dealer always charges more, but if the car is under warranty take it to the dealership. Free repairs are always best.
    References :

  5. Gizmo! Said,

    It has a 12 month warranty because it will not break in 12 months. Go with the cheaper one. It’s an Alternator.
    References :